Fish
Fire
Hike
Bird
Put-in-Bay is a village on South Bass Island in the western basin of Lake Erie, three miles from the Ohio mainland. The island is small, barely four square miles, but the water surrounding it holds the most productive walleye fishery in the world.
The western basin of Lake Erie is shallow (averaging just 24 feet deep), warm relative to the other Great Lakes, and enormously fertile. The nutrient load from the Maumee and Sandusky Rivers feeds a food chain that produces walleye, yellow perch, and smallmouth bass in numbers that no other freshwater system can match. The reef complexes around the Bass Islands, South Bass, Middle Bass, Kelleys Island, are the epicenter, and Put-in-Bay is where the charter fleet docks.
The Western Basin Reefs, Walleye Factory
The limestone reefs surrounding the Bass Islands rise from the lake bottom like underwater plateaus, creating structure that walleye relate to throughout the year. These reefs, along with the extensive reef systems near Kelleys Island and the offshore bars, hold millions of walleye in the western basin.
Spring (April through May) is the first peak. Post-spawn walleye scatter across the reefs and begin feeding aggressively after a winter of minimal activity. The fish hold in 15 to 30 feet of water over the rock and gravel structure, and trolling crankbaits or drifting weight-forward spinners with nightcrawlers produces consistent action. Trophy fish, 28- to 32-inch walleye over eight pounds, are most common in the spring window.
Summer (June through August) pushes walleye deeper as the surface warms. They stack along the thermocline in 30 to 45 feet, and trolling with planer boards and deep-diving crankbaits covers the water to find scattered schools. The fish are smaller on average than spring, but the numbers can be outstanding, 30-fish days are not unusual for a good charter.
Fall (September through November) brings the walleye back shallow as the surface cools. The fall bite is fast, aggressive, and produces some of the best fishing of the year. Fish feed heavily before winter, and the action rivals spring for quality.
Yellow Perch, The Other Gold
Yellow perch are Lake Erie's other claim to fame, the lake holds the largest perch population in the Great Lakes, and the fish grow larger here than almost anywhere else.
Perch fishing peaks in late summer and fall (August through October), when schools stack over the deeper mud flats and rocky structure in 30 to 50 feet. The technique is simple, a spreader rig with emerald shiners on small hooks, lowered to the bottom on a tight line. When you find a school, the action is nonstop, filling a cooler with 10- to 14-inch perch for a fish fry is a Lake Erie tradition.
Perch aren't glamorous, but they taste better than walleye (locals will tell you this quietly) and the fishing is accessible to every skill level.
Smallmouth Bass, The Underappreciated Fishery
The rocky structure around the islands holds smallmouth bass that are often caught incidentally while targeting walleye but deserve dedicated attention. The fish average two to four pounds, with five-pounders caught around the deeper boulder structure.
Bass fishing peaks in late May and June around the spawn, when fish move to the rocky shallows around the islands, and again in fall when they feed aggressively on the same reefs.
The Charter Fleet
Put-in-Bay and the neighboring mainland ports, Port Clinton, Catawba Island, Marblehead, run one of the largest freshwater charter fleets in the country. The boats are purpose-built for walleye trolling: 28- to 36-foot center consoles and walk-arounds rigged with planer boards, downriggers, and rod holders.
Most charters run half-day (5 to 6 hours) or full-day (8 to 10 hours) trips, departing at dawn. The captains know the reef systems intimately, which bars hold fish in which conditions, where the schools are moving on any given day, and that knowledge is the difference between a limit and a slow boat ride.
When to Go
- April–May: Trophy walleye on the reefs, the biggest fish of the year, spring feeding
- June–August: Summer walleye trolling, perch starting, smallmouth bass on the reefs
- September–October: Fall walleye and perch, the best numbers, aggressive fish before winter
- Winter: Ice fishing when conditions allow (not every year on western Erie)
