Fish
Fire
Hike
Bird
Erie, Pennsylvania sits on the southern shore of Lake Erie, where a dozen small tributary creeks drain the hillsides and empty into the lake. For most of the year, these creeks are unremarkable, narrow, shallow, tree-lined streams you could step across in places. But twice a year, when Lake Erie steelhead push upstream to spawn, these creeks transform into some of the best steelhead fishing east of the Rocky Mountains.
The stretch of Lake Erie shoreline from Cattaraugus Creek in New York west through Pennsylvania and into Ohio is collectively known as Steelhead Alley, and Erie, Pennsylvania is the heart of it.
The Fall Run, October Through December
The fall steelhead run begins in October when cooling water temperatures and autumn rains swell the tributaries. Lake Erie steelhead, chrome-bright fish of three to ten pounds, with occasional fish over 12, push upstream from the lake into the creek systems to stage and eventually spawn.
Elk Creek is the most famous and productive tributary. The lower sections from the mouth upstream to Folly's End offer the most consistent fishing, with steelhead holding in the pools, runs, and behind the ledges that define the stream's character. The creek is wadeable, accessible from public access points, and holds fish from October through April.
Walnut Creek runs through the Erie suburbs and receives strong steelhead runs despite its urban setting. Trout Run, Godfrey Run, and Crooked Creek are smaller but productive, and the lesser-known eastern creeks, Sixteen Mile, Twenty Mile, offer more solitude.
The fall technique is nymphing, drifting egg patterns, sucker spawn flies, and small nymphs through the pools and runs where steelhead hold. The takes are subtle, a hesitation in the drift, a slight pull, and then the fish is airborne, running downstream through the creek, and you're chasing it over slippery rocks. A fresh chrome steelhead in a small creek is one of the most exciting freshwater fights in the East.
The Spring Run, March Through May
The spring run is the spawning push. Steelhead that have been in the creeks through winter, plus fresh fish entering from the lake, move to the gravel bars and shallow riffles to spawn. The fish are less chrome than fall arrivals, they've colored up over the winter, but they're aggressive, and the spring run often produces the highest numbers.
March and April are the peak months. The technique shifts to a mix of nymphing, swing fishing with streamers, and sight-fishing to visible fish on the spawning beds (where regulations allow). The spring run coincides with the snow melting, and the combination of steelhead fishing and late-winter-into-spring weather makes for a raw, physical experience.
Lake Erie, Walleye, Perch, and Smallmouth
Beyond the tributaries, Lake Erie itself offers open-water fishing from Presque Isle Bay and the Erie harbor.
Walleye are the primary lake target. Erie sits on the eastern basin transition, deeper and colder than the western basin around Put-in-Bay, and the walleye here tend to run larger on average. Trolling crankbaits and worm harnesses along the eastern basin's thermocline produces fish from May through October.
Yellow perch fill the nearshore water in summer and fall, with the September-through-November perch bite drawing crowds of anglers fishing from boats and the Presque Isle piers.
Smallmouth bass hold on the rocky structure in Presque Isle Bay and along the lakefront. The bay's clear, shallow water allows sight-fishing for smallmouth in the spring.
Presque Isle Bay, The Sheltered Water
Presque Isle is a sandy peninsula curving into Lake Erie, creating a protected bay that holds a multispecies fishery separate from the open lake. Largemouth bass hold in the weedy bays. Steelhead stage in the bay before entering the creeks in fall. Perch are the summer constant.
The bay is accessible from shore, the Presque Isle State Park offers miles of fishing access from the peninsula's beaches and shoreline.
When to Go
- October–December: Fall steelhead run in the tributaries, the main event
- March–May: Spring steelhead, walleye opening on the lake, perch starting
- June–August: Open-lake walleye trolling, smallmouth in Presque Isle Bay, perch
- September: Transition, early steelhead in the creeks, perch peaking on the lake
